How can agriculture modernise Africa? And does the road to the cities really lead out of poverty? Reiner Klingholz from the Berlin Institute for Population and Development in conversation with Jan Rübel.
Dr. Reiner Klingholz is director and board member of the Berlin-Institute for Population and Development. Previously, he was a member of the Enquete Commission on Demographic Change in Lower Saxony and worked as a Fellow at the Stellenborsch Institute for Advanced Studies in South Africa.
Mr. Klingholz, Africa’s young people are running for the cities. Can this trend be stopped? Dr. Reiner Klingholz: No. This urbanisation is caused by new job opportunities tending to be created where a critical mass of businesses, research institutions, and sharp minds come together – at least a few hundreds of thousands of people in one place. Ideas become new products and jobs. In times gone by, one needed coal and iron ore from the ground. In this day and age, however, knowledge is the basis for jobs.
Is that also true for Germany? This trend can be observed globally. In the German federal state of Vorpommern, there are relatively few innovative businesses, and in Berlin, a new one is started every 20 hours. In Africa, urbanisation also has additional dimensions: The high population growth occurs mainly in the rural regions. This is where the number of children is higher than it is in the city. And the number of jobs can keep up much less than it could in the urban regions. So young people migrate to the city because they are hoping to find better job prospects there. Futhermore, the people enjoy more freedom in the cities than the countryside where more social repression happens.
In the rural regions, most people work in the agriculture sector. How does this affect the young generation? They see how much hard work it is. The businesses are small and self-sustained. They cultivate crop for their own consumption and barely make money from it. Due to the high population growth, the fields become smaller and smaller. Young people are no longer interested in this traditional form of agriculture and for this tedious work. It is a trap. It means poverty and is yet the cause of a continuous population growth with high birth rates – a vicious circle.
And the farmers, male and female, are becoming older? This is why the population actively working in agriculture is getting older, obviously. It is mostly women who work in the fields. The agriculture sector must change fundamentally.
Does it still need to do that or is this already happening?
Essentially, it still needs to change. After all, it is very difficult for people to escape the subsistence economy all by themselves. Modernisation and sustainable intensification are required. Productivity must increase in order to allow Africa to feed itself. Modern technology and higher chances of profit will make the sector more attractive for young people. What is important is downstream processing and that primary agricultural products become marketable food items. This is how money is made, and how new jobs are created. These young people do not merely want to stand in the field with pick and shovel...
... Otherwise they will go to the city and programme an app? Is this step not a little drastic? But this is exactly what’s already happening. It is not the perfect solution, however, given that there is not enough work in the cities. There is no doubt that people in the cities are better off than those in the countryside. Life expectancy in the cities is higher. Income levels are higher, and opportunities for education are better despite the fact that many people live in the worst slums.
Do the young people in the cities live like the British workers that Karl Marx used to describe? It is possible that this is a transition phase on the road to industrialisation. However, we do not know what consequences this would bring for Africa. Even with rapid industrialisation, it will be hard to find work for all those who are looking. Africa’s main problem is that the population fit for work is growing faster than the number of jobs available. This is the root cause of all social and political conflicts: young people who do not find a suitable place in society tend to choose radical solutions.
Why can agriculture become an engine for job creation? Why not the industrial sector or the service sector? This is because any country that has ever undergone such a development has started out in agriculture. With a growing agricultural sector, not only more people will have food, but they will also be healthier. Human capital is made through education and health. Adequate nutrition is essential for this purpose. Children with an empty stomach cannot learn. In the agriculture sector, jobs are created especially when you add the downstream sector: It goes without saying that, initially, jobs will be lost when the pick is replaced with a combine harvester. However, this also creates more and better paid jobs in processing what the farmers produce. The most large-scale structural change that Europe has ever undergone was away from agriculture and towards the industrial society. 80 percent of people used to work in agriculture. Today it is only one or two percent. Those who lost their jobs as farmers become available for more productive and innovative jobs that formed the basis of the wealth of these people. This is not only based on the agricultural sector but that’s where it first began.
Was this structural change back then in Europe larger in scale than the current one caused by digitalisation?
Without a doubt. The proportion of people affected by it was much higher.
What is the beginning of agricultural modernisation – Is it education? It is a combination of education and the use of knowledge. New techniques and tools, better quality seeds, and artificial fertilizer have all once been invented in Europe. Africa can build on this knowledge and avoid the mistakes that we made. Africa can focus on digitalisation from the very beginning: For example, the farmers can use sensors to measure humidity and nutrient levels in the fields, and they can use irrigation only when it is actually required.
What mistakes that were made in Europe can be avoided? Exposure to pesticides, overfertilising the land, and the threat to drinking water are all challenges that Africa needs to overcome. As well as the wrong type of subsidies, those that might lead to overproduction and distorted prices, should be avoided.
There are two schools of thoughts: The one preaches about the strictly necessary green revolution, and the second insists on ecological farming. Where do you stand on this issue? The truth lies somewhere between the two. Not everything falling under even the broadest definition of genetic engineering should be deemed useless because of the technology used. We have to see what advantages that can be gained from this technology. Technology alone does not make a product evil. However, it does not necessarily make a product useful. With seeds for example, revenue can be increased and other properties desired can usually be realised, using traditional methods of crop cultivation. In individual cases, hybrids can be helpful, for new pests that have come about due to climate change, for example.
Small farmers, leading an contemplative life in harmony with the environment is a naive idea
And what about fertiliser? Soil in Africa is no worse than soil in Europe, on average. However, using organic fertiliser is challenging given the degradation rate of organic fertilisers. This rate is very high due to the climate in Africa. I can barely imagine how intensifying activities in the agriculture sector can be possible without artificial fertiliser. Africa cannot do this without this type of fertiliser. Having said that, it must not be used either according to the motto of: Using a lot helps a lot. In Europe we did this for a long time, with all the damage to our soil and our water that resulted from this. What Africa needs is precision farming using any technique possible to increase revenue but without destroying the basis of agricultural work. This is called sustainable. There is no alternative to it.
Is the issue of land access a problem for young people? Land rights are a general problem in Africa. In many places, the land is owned by the state. This makes it hard to motivate farmers to make long-term investments. Alternatively, there may be big landowners who hire people but only pay them the absolute minimum. In an ideal world, every farmer should be able to farm and keep their own land. This is when farmers develop the level of responsibility required. After all, the farmer will still need his land tomorrow, and he might also want to pass it on to his children.
How can this situation be addressed? Some countries give access to land through reforms. Where the areas are too small, agriculture cannot become productive. Then you have to have co-operations in which people share machines. Nobody will buy a tractor to farm half a hectare of land. The goal should be to ultimately combine small surfaces. For example, one farmer sells his land because he is taking up a different type of employment, and his neighbour, who purchases the land, will then increase his area. The idea, partially promoted by Europe, that small farmers have a quiet and peaceful life with the people around them that needs to be preserved is naive. The only thing that will be preserved this way is the poverty trap.
How should big players be viewed in this context – as an opportunity or as a curse? It is hard for me to make this judgement. Research is not conclusive. It could be that a big investor may be able to increase productivity massively and that the country benefits from this. However, the example of Ethiopia shows that productivity can be increased even for small cultivation areas: The government employs tens of thousands of agricultural advisors, and it is offering better seeds. The negative scenario is that a large investor from outside comes, hires only a few people, and that this person will then take both the products and the revenue out of the country. Investors from outside need not be bad. After all, one problem of African agriculture is that the means for the investments needed are lacking.
Why has this potential of agriculture been missed? Agriculture has long been viewed as not sexy by development programmes. The governments wanted to build roads, bring industry to the country, establish a banking sector fast, and extract raw material from the ground. Agriculture is a lot of work initially, and the population working in this sector does not have a very high status. Young people at university level are looking to work in the administrative sector, to become doctors or engineers, but not farmers. There is an issue with the image of the sector. This is yet another reason why agriculture needs to be modernised.
Have the developed countries also missed the boat with Africa in this context? Back when development cooperation was still referred to as development, people used to say this: We will take our machines and our technology there, and everything will be okay. This approach was naive because the knowledge required was lacking. There have been a lot of severe failure. White elephants were placed in the fields. The machines would rot away while the farmers would continue their traditional type of agriculture.
If population growth does not slow down, people will remain trapped in the poverty trap.
Is there are time window for modernising agriculture, or is it never too late? Compared to other regions, Africa is just running late and trying to catch up. This makes it even more important to act fast. Countries need to develop quickly, and their people need perspectives. Without perspectives, they cannot plan their lives which makes family planning difficult as well. Along with development and better education, the number of childbirths will decrease. This is the only way to solve Africa’s biggest problem – the fast population growth. There is no humane alternative to this. When population growth does not slow down rapidly, people will remain trapped in the poverty trap. This will have horrendous, almost Malthusian, consequences: A lot of people will starve. Mortality rates will rise, and distribution conflicts will increase. Nobody wants this to happen.
A report by Alexander Müller and Jes Weigelt (TMG)
As the climate changes, the population of Africa is growing and fertile land and jobs are becoming scarcer. New ways are currently leading to urbanisation of agriculture and a new mid-sized sector in the countryside
Does Africa's youth want to live in the city or in the country? Which career path seems particularly attractive? And how optimistic are the young people about the future? Young adults from rural areas answered these questions by SMS.
In western Africa a new middle class is emerging. Their consumer behaviour is determining the demand for products – home-produced and imported goods, on the internet or at the village market. The people of Ivory Coast in particular are looking to the future with optimism.
Happy youngsters in rural areas, green development and the connection to the digital age – professor Joachim von Braun believes in this future sceneraio for Africa. For three decades the agricultural scienties has been researching how politics can create prosperty on the continent.
A report by T. S. Jayne, A. Adelaja and R. Mkandawire
Thirty years ago, Africa was synonymous with war, famine and poverty. That narrative is clearly outdated. African living standards are rising remarkably fast. Our authors are convinced that improving education and entrepreneurship will ensure irreversible progress in the region even as it confronts COVID-19.
Startups are booming in African agriculture. What are the current trend and challenges – and can other regions benefit from innovative approaches? A Video-Interview with Claudia Makadristo, Regional Manager of Seedstars
A contribution by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation
Africa’s population is young and ready to take its destiny into its own hands. Agriculture offers amazing opportunities in this regard. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation wants to support the next generation in this way.
A quick and cost-effective method calculates living wages and incomes for many different countries. The GIZ together with Fairtrade International and Richard and Martha Anker have developed a tool that companies can use to easily analyse income and wage gaps.
At the moment, the agricultural industries of African countries exist in relative isolation. Imagine peasant farmers digitally connected to the value chains of the global food industry. How could this happen? A guidebook.
Interview with Gnininkaboka Dabiré and Innocent Somé
Later on you want to become a farmer yourself, or would you prefer to take up another profession? Two young people from Burkina-Faso talked to representatives of the Dreyer Foundation about their parents' farms, the profession of farmer and their own plans for the future.
The soybean is a natural crop that can be used to make a lot of food. So, Tata Bi started a small processing business first on her own, then with a few other women, which provides the women with an additional source of income year-round besides selling the soybeans.
Africa has a huge opportunity to make agriculture its economic driver. However, the potential for this is far from being made exhaustive use of, one reason being that women face considerable difficulties in their economic activities. The organisation AWAN Afrika seeks to change this state of affairs.
What contribution does development cooperation make to conflict prevention? What can it do for sustainable peace? Political scientist Karina Mroß talks to Raphael Thelen about post-conflict societies and their chances for peaceful development.
What do electrical engineering, telecommunications and agriculture have in common? They arouse the passion of Strive Masiyiwa: Thirty years ago, he started an electrical installation company with $75, later riding the telecommunications wave as a pioneer. Today he is committed to transforming African agriculture.
The Cashew Council is the first international organisation for a raw material stemming from Africa. The industry promises to make progress in processing and refining cashew nuts - and answers to climate change
Fish is important for combating malnutrition and undernourishment. But it is not only notable for its nutritional value, but also secures the livelihoods and employment for 600 million people worldwide.
The world’s population keeps on growing; with this rise comes an increased need for food as well as productive employment opportunities. Offering young people in rural areas better employment prospects is one of the objectives of the sector project. The young population is the key to a modern and efficient agricultural economy.
Africa is home to the world’s youngest and fastest growing population. For many young people, agriculture could offer a job perspective. But to improve the living conditions and job prospects of young people in rural areas, political reforms and investments are desperately needed, as these people will be at the centre of agriculture and agricultural development in the future.
Joe DeVries is a breeder – and Vice President of AGRA (Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa). What are the chances and risks of a ’green revolution‘ in Africa? A discourse between Jan Rübel and him about productivity, needs, and paternalism.
Stefan Liebing is chairman of the Africa Association of German Business. The manager calls for a better structure of African farms. Jan Rübel asked him about small farmers, the opportunities for German start-ups and a new fund.
What happens when young people leave the rural areas? How can the region achieve what is referred to as the demographic bonus – and how can it reap the benefits of the demographic dividend? A look at demography shows the following: What is most important is promoting women’s rights and education.
A contribution by Dr. Karin Gaesing and Prof. Dr. Frank Bliss (INEF)
Especially in densely populated areas, land pressure leads to overexploitation of available land and a lack of conservation measures. The West African country of Benin, with heavily depleted soils in many places, is no exception.
In Eastern El Salvador, campesinos are cultivating a self-image to encourage rural youth to remain in rural areas. With help from Caritas, they have adjusted the cultivation methods to their soils and traditions - Marvin Antonio Garcia Otero,the deputy director of Caritas of the Diocese of San Miguel believes this is the best way to prevent rural exodus and criminality.
The United Nations plan a Food Systems Summit - and now the Corona-Virus is dictating the agenda. The Chief Economist of the UN World Food Programme takes stock of the current situation: a conversation with Jan Rübel about pandemics, about the chromosomes of development - and about the conflicts that inhibit them.
This is a benchmark for everybody: More rights for women are a very influencing solution in the struggle against extreme poverty and hunger worldwide, says Stephan Exo-Kreischer, Director of ONE Germany. The organisation specialises in political campaigning as a lever for sustainable change.
It is 2080. We are on a farm somewhere in Africa. Everything is digital. The blockchain is an omnipotent point of reference, and the farm is flourishing. But then, everything goes wrong. A dystopian short story, written exclusively for SEWOH.
Lack of seasonal workers and virus explosion in slaughterhouses, rising vegetable prices, climate crisis – all this demonstrates: Our food system is highly productive and (at least for the rich inhabitants of planet earth) guarantees an unprecedented rich and steady food supply - but it is not resilient.
At the beginning of December 2018, AGRA's board of directors met in Berlin. The "Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa" panel discussed the next steps in their policy of modernizing agriculture. How to go on in the next ten years? One question - many answers from experts.
A contritbution by Essa Chanie Mussa (University of Gondar)
Rural youth need viable livelihood opportunities to escape out of poverty and realize their aspirations. How could they be helped to fully unleash their potential? This is an aloud call that needs novel strategies among governments, policy makers, and international development partners and donors.
As President of the IABM cooperative in Muhanga, Alphonsine Mukankusi is not simply focused on the figures. She has learned how to deal with people and how to take on responsibility. At the same time, her work helps her to come to terms with the past
Agnes Kalibata, AGRA president since 2014 and former minister of agriculture and wildlife in Rwanda, is convinced that Africa's economy will only grow sustainably if small-scale agriculture is also seen as an opportunity.
Interview with Paul Newnham, Director of the SDG 2 Advocacy Hub.
The UN Food Systems pre-Summit in Rome dealt with transforming the ways of our nutrition. How do you bring that to a broad public? Questions to Paul Newnham, the Director of the Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 2 Advocacy Hub.
Interview with Martina Fleckenstein (WWF), Michael Kühn (WHH) and Christel Weller-Molongua (GIZ)
After the summit means pre-summit: It was the first time that the United Nations held a summit on food systems. Martina Fleckenstein, Michael Kühn and Christel Weller-Molongua reviewed the situation in this joint interview.
Genetically modified bacteria become edible proteins, cows graze on pasture, and no waste is produced in an industrial circular economy. Journalist Jan Grossarth sees a silver lining for the future of world nutrition
Supporting groups of smallholding women substantially contributes to strengthen rural operations economically. The organisation and associated group activities can help to reduce extreme poverty and improve the food situation.
Besides the well known impacts of Covid19 lockdowns for the adult population, the associated school closures led to 90 percent of the world’s children with no access to schools. However, school meals are in often the only daily meal for children. Without access to this safety net, issues like hunger, poverty and malnutrition are exacerbated for hundreds of millions of children.
The majority of producers in developing countries are women. Although they contribute significantly to the food security of their families, they remain chronically disadvantaged in male-dominated agriculture in terms of access to land, credit, technology and education.
A contribution by Nadine Babatounde and Anne Floquet (MISEREOR)
To prevent malnutrition among young children and strengthen the role of women in their communities, Misereor, together with the local non-governmental organisation CEBEDES, is implementing a programme on integrated home gardens in Benin - a series of pictures.
Africa's cotton production plays a key role in the fight against poverty. The "Cotton Made in Africa" initiative promotes sustainable cultivation - one element of which is the use of organic pesticides. Entomologist Ben Sekamatte and cotton company manager Boaz Ogola talked with Jan Rübel about soil and yields.
What are the consequences of using synthetic pesticides in agriculture? Where do they help, where do they harm? Lena Luig, expert for the development policy organization INKOTA, and science journalist Ludger Weß discuss this controversial topic of international scope.
A contribution by Kerstin Weber and Brit Reichelt-Zolho (WWF)
Biodiversity and sustainable agriculture ensure the nutrition of whole societies. But there is more: These two factors also provide better protection against the outbreak of dangerous pandemics. Hence, the question of preserving ecosystems is becoming a global survival issue.
A contribution by Dr. May Hokan and Dr. Arnulf Köhncke (WWF)
Due to the coronavirus crisis, the connection between human and animal health has gained new attention. Politicians and scientists are joining forces to propagate the solution: One Health. But what is behind the concept? And can it also guarantee food security for all people worldwide?
Double interview with Tony Rinaudo and Volker Schlöndorff
Tony Rinaudo uses conventional reforestation methods to plant millions and millions of trees – and Volker Schlöndorff is filming a cinema documentary about the Australian. The outcome so far: An educational film on behalf of the BMZ (Federal Ministry for Economic Co-operation and Development).
Urban gardening is becoming increasingly popular in northern metropoles. People who consider themselves part of a green movement are establishing productive gardens in the city, for example on rooftops or in vacant lots. In severely impoverished regions of the global South, urban agriculture is a component of the food strategy.
Interview with Bernadette Arakwiye und Salima Mahamoudou (World Resources Institute)
Deforestation is leading to a shortage of ressources. What are the options for counteracting? A conversation with Bernadette Arakwiye and Salima Mahamoudou about renaturation and the possibilities of artificial intelligence.
It began with clicks at a trade fair and ends with concrete reforestation: a campaign at the Green Week in Berlin is now enriching the forests of the Yen Bai Province in Vietnam. A chronicle of an education about climatic relevance to concrete action - and about the short distances on our planet.
A report by Bettina Rudloff and Annette Weber (SWP)
The Corona-Virus exacerbates existing crises through conflict, climate, hunger and locusts in East Africa and the Horn of Africa. What needs to be done in these regions? To face these challenges for many countries, all of these crises need to be captured in their regional context.
In this article, the author describes what we know about interlinkages, what role agriculture has to play in the sustainable use and conservation of biodiversity, and what the necessary changes in agricultural systems might look like, both on small and large-scale farms.
A Contribution by Emile Frison and Nick Jacobs (IPES-Food)
While having failed to solve the hunger problem, industrial agriculture appears to be causing additional ones both in environmental and health terms. Emile Frison and Nick Jacobs call for a transformation.
Indian farmers restore precious soil material combining traditional with innovative approaches. A case example how governance, agriculture and development cooperation can work together to combat climate change.